Monday, 14 October 2013

Research and Planning: Critical Theories of Narrative

Vladimir Propp's theory of events are as follows: 

Characters as Function-

  • The Hero- who is the character who seeks something.
  • The Villain- who opposes or block's the hero's quest.
  • The Donor- who provides an object which has some magic property.
  • The Dispatcher- who sends the hero on his way by providing a message. 
  • The False Hero- who disrupts the hero's hope of reward by pressing false claims.
  • The Helper- who aids the hero.
  • The Princess- who acts as reward for the hero and as object of the villain's scheming.
  • Her Father- who acts to reward the hero for his efforts
Actions as Function- 
  • Preparation- A community, Kingdom, family; an ordered state of being
  • Complication- A state of disorder 
  • Transference 
  • Struggle
  • Return
  • Recognition


Tzvetan Todorov's theory is as follows:
  • A state of EQUILIBRIUM (all is in order)
  • A disruption of the ordered state by an event
  • A recognition that a disruption has taken place 
  • An attempt to repair the damage of the disruption 
  • A return to some kind of Equilibrium


Branigan's Categories of Information:
  • Introduction of setting and characters 
  • Explanation of a state of affairs (Expedition)
  • Initiating event (Hook) 
  • Emotional response or statement of a goal by the protagonist 
  • Complicating actions (Plot)
  • Outcome 
  • Reactions to the outcome ('Happy endings', Equilibrium or Someone dies) 

I agree with Propp and Todorov's views on narrative as they clearly list the theories behind narrative whereas I do agree with some of  Branigan's points his views are from a psychoanalysis view. 



1 comment:

  1. not enough to earn marks yet - extend and show understanding by adding examples and clips of films that meet each theoretical concept... they could be from the short films we analysed or from elsewhere - blockbusters - perhaps one theory suits short films more than another theory? try to get this done for the 21st oct

    ReplyDelete